Sicily's Pizza & Pasta

Review №1

Rating: 3

Date: 3 weeks ago

Review №2

Rating: 5

Received a recommendation to visit a little ol hole-in-the-wall Itallian restaurant. The host had some chops and the servers had great attitudes. Our server, Clara, aka Clara-bell, has been on the job for 2 weeks and had her menu down. Upgrade to the Sicilys salad. The rolls are literally loaves and the baked ziti had the perfect amount of ricotta cheese.

Date: 4 weeks ago

Review №3

Rating: 5

Date: a month ago

Review №4

Rating: 5

Best grilled chicken salad in all of North Texas!!! Dans Salad the best!

Date: a month ago

Review №5

Rating: 5

Date: a month ago

Review №6

Rating: 5

WONDERFUL SERVICE! And the BEST food! My husband and I come here a lot but this time it was for a ladies networking luncheon and they were amazing! The restaurant was PACKED but everything went so smooth! Thank you to the amazing owner and the wonderful waitress who served us!

Date: a month ago

Review №7

Rating: 5

Date: 2 months ago

Review №8

Rating: 5

We felt like we discovered a hidden gem in McKinney. The GIGANTIC rolls were amazing, and food was delicious and reasonably priced. Normally we would take pics of the food, but it was so good and we were so hungry it was devoured too quickly! Well definitely be back.

Date: 2 months ago

Review №9

Rating: 1

We have been here 3-4 times and it s been so so, last time they gave us fresh bread and butter, we didn t even ask, this time the salad was small with 1 tomato slice, we asked and were told thats what they are told to put on it and that other people don t like tomatoes! The owner came by we told him and he said we could have asked for more! Really? Then why didn t our server tell us? And I asked about the bread and he said we could have ordered it! When I go out to eat, I don t want excuses! Never going back!

Date: 2 months ago

Review №10

Rating: 5

Date: 2 months ago

Review №11

Rating: 5

The food taste really good. My husband and I ate there for first time. He had the Salmon and I had a personal pizza with a salad.

Date: 3 months ago

Review №12

Rating: 5

Date: 3 months ago

Review №13

Rating: 5

Date: 3 months ago

Review №14

Rating: 4

Great food!

Date: 3 months ago

Review №15

Rating: 5

We ordered delivery from UberEats. My wife can t tolerate gluten. She was so excited to see a gluten-free margarita pizza. She loved it. Dietary restrictions: Gluten-free pizza was excellent

Date: 4 months ago

Review №16

Rating: 4

The food is very good. I love the pasta sampler.

Date: 4 months ago

Review №17

Rating: 5

Second time we stopped for lunch. Always friendly prompt service. We ordered Spaghetti and Baked Ziti plus took a Pizza to go. Each time we enjoyed our food and quality was consistent with previous visit. Definitely a good spot for tasty Italian food for reasonable prices. We will be back!

Date: 4 months ago

Review №18

Rating: 1

Date: 4 months ago

Review №19

Rating: 5

Date: 4 months ago

Review №20

Rating: 5

Date: 4 months ago

Review №21

Rating: 5

Date: 4 months ago

Review №22

Rating: 5

Georgia and the rest of the staff were friendly and all did well. Food was excellent, and plentiful.

Date: 5 months ago

Review №23

Rating: 5

A local staple. Sicilys is the best Italian restaurant in town, and they also have the best prices. I always get the manicotti. I have tried this dish at other, more expensive places, and none of them do it as good as Sicilys! They also have free bread, which is crunchy and delicious. They have pizza by the slice, which is also pretty good, especially if you have picky eaters!

Date: 5 months ago

Review №24

Rating: 5

We love coming here always! Great food and pizza! Love the friendly reception and attention to us as a friend! The BYoB feature is handy at times! I love this great place!

Date: 5 months ago

Review №25

Rating: 3

Called in curbside order. Made it to the restaurant, called number on sign for curbside. Girl on the phone said she would be out in about 5 to take payment and bring pizza (one 12 inch pizza) waited 25 minutes and no one came out. Had to go inside to get order. No acknowledgment of no one coming out to deliver said curbside order. Inside was not busy, maybe 3 tables. Just disappointed.

Date: 5 months ago

Review №26

Rating: 5

Love their gluten-free pizza. I can not have tomato sauce, so they do an olive oil base. My husband loves their ravioli, and they bake fresh rolls daily. They have byob, which is a great savings.

Date: 5 months ago

Review №27

Rating: 4

Date: 5 months ago

Review №28

Rating: 3

Decent little place in town. The service was good and the price was good. Vegetarian options: It s Italian, so they have salads, pizza with veggie options and pasta dishes that don t have meat. Kid-friendliness: Pizza & lots of seating.

Date: 6 months ago

Review №29

Rating: 5

Best damn tiramisu ever

Date: 6 months ago

Review №30

Rating: 5

Excellent waitstaff. Very professional and courteous.

Date: 6 months ago

Review №31

Rating: 4

The atmosphere rating could range from 3 to 5 depending on what kind of place you like. Its a neighborhood Italian place. You wont see any sommeliers, in fact its BYOB. Pro-tip: if you forget, theres a WinCo right across the street and they sell wine. Sicilys has some corkscrews you can borrow. What you will find is staff that is largely composed of local high school students for the wait staff, and more experienced folks doing the actual cooking. That combination of well-made Italian-American classics and enthusiastic service from smiling young men and women makes this whole thing click. The management obviously makes it very clear that customer service is paramount, because you will get a lot of smiles and attentive service. The food is good, high quality American style Italian favorites - lasagna, pizza, spaghetti and meatballs, chicken Marsala/piccata/parmesean, and others in that vein. Im always happy with the quality of the food and the price point is very reasonable.

Date: 7 months ago

Review №32

Rating: 5

Date: 7 months ago

Review №33

Rating: 5

Date: 7 months ago

Review №34

Rating: 5

Date: 7 months ago

Review №35

Rating: 5

Food was delicious, plentiful, and affordable. The bread rolls are giant and very soft and yummy. Customer service is top-notch at this family owned and ran restaurant, and they do a lot to support the community and especially the police.

Date: 7 months ago

Review №36

Rating: 5

Great food, staff is great .

Date: 7 months ago

Review №37

Rating: 1

Undoubtedly the worst experience we ve had. The waitresses were great but the food and owner/manager was not even subpar. He was argumentative and did not care if you were you unhappy about the food at all. The wait time for the order was way out of normal wait times. When my order came out it was incorrect so I ordered a salad instead because I didn t want to wait for the entree again. Everyone had completed their meal before the salad came out. The chicken in the salad was so tough I couldn t eat it. The lettuce was good but very little of that. We wondered why there was more pickup orders than people dining and we know why now service takes waaaaay to long. Will not try it for a second time if it were free.

Date: 7 months ago

Review №38

Rating: 5

Perfect hole-in-the-wall place to eat Italian.

Date: 7 months ago

Review №39

Rating: 1

The year was around 2016. When my friend had cancer and just got out of the hospital, after having part of her body amputated. She couldnt get out of bed after having a chunk of her body cut out and her 3 children were hungry. I called in an order to Sicilys McKinney TX. I had been at least 20+ times and had spoken with the owner in friendly passing. I went to get the food and explained the situation to the owner. I asked if he could donate the food or give a discount under the circumstances, which I did fully explain. NOOOO!!! then he stormed off. I paid for 100% the food and got the opportunity to be a blessing to someone in need. Ill NEVER set foot in this establishment after being responded to with such abrasiveness. UPDATE** A friend went in and asked him about that event. He knew nothing of it. Isnt that strange...... He then began giving food in front of said friend. Maybe he learned his lesson or maybe its all part of the show.... Look good now because word got around. Pathetic! As for my friend that was fighting cancer. SHE BEAT IT!!!

Date: 8 months ago

Review №40

Rating: 5

Date: 8 months ago

Review №41

Rating: 5

Date: 8 months ago

Review №42

Rating: 3

I have eaten here many times over the last 14 years. On this particular occasion I was dismayed. I tried to call in an order a few times but no answer. I assumed it was due to being a Friday night. When I arrived it did not seem so busy maybe less than half full. I placed an order to go and sat down across from cashier. I over heard them saying to go orders were very heavy, yet I never heard the phone ring once. I noticed a bag placed on pass thru and thought it might be my order. I observed wait staff chit chatting and being on phones. After several minutes I observed the lady who took my order look at the slips in front of her, she then turned to the pass thru and looked at the bag, sure enough it was mine. After sitting there I had to heat it back up. Somewhat disappointing though even reheating the food was ok. Seems like they need better leadership or guidance, might explain why the mMexican place behind them was packed .

Date: 8 months ago

Review №43

Rating: 1

Ordered from Ubereats. Alfredo Pasta was possibly the worst Ive ever had in my life. Tastes only like butter. Bread was hard & the Cannoli tasted like weak cream cheese in 3 day old bread. Cheesecake was OK but overpriced.

Date: 9 months ago

Review №44

Rating: 5

Best pizza ever! Huge portions. BYOB! We love Sicilys. Family friendly and fantastic staff.

Date: 9 months ago

Review №45

Rating: 5

Date: 9 months ago

Review №46

Rating: 5

Date: 9 months ago

Review №47

Rating: 5

Food portions are VERY large. Their pasta is amazing. My friends are obsessed with their salad. But the best thing of all...THEIR HOMEMADE RANCH

Date: 9 months ago

Review №48

Rating: 5

Best Italian around!! Owners are always there and they are super friendly and make you feel welcome!! Food is always EXCELLENT!

Date: 9 months ago

Review №49

Rating: 5

Food and service is always great!

Date: 9 months ago

Review №50

Rating: 5

Date: 9 months ago

Review №51

Rating: 5

We love sicilys. The pizza is the closest to NY style we have found. When you take a slice the cheese oozes and the crust is crisp on the edges.. Yummy

Date: 9 months ago

Review №52

Rating: 5

Date: 9 months ago

Review №53

Rating: 1

I ordered a 12 inch cheese pizza, which I would not order again. The crust was okay a bit too soft & soggy. Cheese was overpowering & had a weird buttery taste.. the marinara was OK. I think the garlic rolls were most disappointing. You get a mountain of cold bread with no garlic flavor what so ever. Marinara for the garlic rolls was tasty. It s messy when you walk in & a mess behind the register which made me question the kitchen s condition. The dining area was clean though.

Date: 9 months ago

Review №54

Rating: 5

Date: 9 months ago

Review №55

Rating: 2

Service was the best thing about this place. Food was not worth going back for.

Date: 10 months ago

Review №56

Rating: 5

Date: 10 months ago

Review №57

Rating: 5

Date: 10 months ago

Review №58

Rating: 5

Date: 10 months ago

Review №59

Rating: 5

Date: 10 months ago

Review №60

Rating: 4

Date: 10 months ago

Review №61

Rating: 4

Date: 11 months ago

Review №62

Rating: 5

How do I say this? Delicious pizza! I ve been ISO a delicious, Italian-quality cheese pizza that satisfies my old husband, our teen, our toddler, and my 33-year-old-ish self and THIS takes the front seat! Just in town for the week and we ate here twice! Thanks, Sicily s Pizza and Pasta!

Date: 11 months ago

Review №63

Rating: 5

Wait staff was wonderful, and the lasagna was really good. The bread that came with meal was good as well.

Date: 11 months ago

Review №64

Rating: 5

A small family-run place sharing their love of food with their customers :) Love this place and highly recommend. Recommended dishes

Date: 11 months ago

Review №65

Rating: 3

My expectations were high. The pizza did not live upto them. It was too bland. Base was too chewy and the toppings were stale.

Date: 11 months ago

Review №66

Rating: 5

My go to place for comfort food.

Date: 11 months ago

Review №67

Rating: 5

We have been searching for a GREAT Pizza in Mckinney for about 6 years and found it here. I would recommend Sicilys pizza for anyone wanting a great pizza!

Date: 11 months ago

Review №68

Rating: 5

We went for Saturday dinner and had a wonderful meal!! We ordered The Sicilys Salad for two and it has fresh sliced mushrooms, black olives, lettuce, tomato wedges, and lots of fresh shredded mozzarella cheese, of course with the house red tomato vinaigrette. We both ordered the lasagna and it was delicious, the sauce was superb with a nice layer of cheese on top. The Owner visited our table and we talked about the sauce which is a Labor of Love, thick, flavorful and rich from the extended cooking process. BYOB: we brought our own Italian Red Wine, from Italy. I Love that this restaurant is still a great place for 20+ years, That Matters!!

Date: 11 months ago

Review №69

Rating: 5

Just from the reviews alone, you can tell this is a lot like most other Italian places. The difference between this place and another is that this restaurant is a real good family location with amazing architecture and amazing and unique food

Date: a year ago

Review №70

Rating: 5

Fried zucchini was really good and everything else was great!!! Awesome service Parking: Good access to restaurant. Food : 5/5 |

Date: a year ago

Review №71

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №72

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №73

Rating: 3

Date: a year ago

Review №74

Rating: 2

My family has been going to Sicilys for probably 20 years. Lately the sauce that is being used for spaghetti, baked ziti and other dishes requiring sauce is very different than it used to be. When the parents were running this restaurant, the sauce was so good you just couldnt get enough. The last 3 times we have eaten there (3 times because we forget the sauce tastes bad) I can only take a few bites before the taste of the sauce sickens me. Too bad because we ate here at least once a week. We cant return because the sauce is just so horrible now, it tastes like canned sauce. We now drive all the way to Celina to eat at an Italian Restaurant that is very reminiscent of Sicilys before the bad sauce.

Date: a year ago

Review №75

Rating: 5

:) great service and pizza was deeelicious thanks

Date: a year ago

Review №76

Rating: 5

We love Siciliy. The goop is great on their fresh baked bread, the calamari is Devine, and the pizza....reason why we keep coming back

Date: a year ago

Review №77

Rating: 2

Very hard bread and a bit bland

Date: a year ago

Review №78

Rating: 4

Date: a year ago

Review №79

Rating: 5

Been coming for 25 years. No dish has ever let us down.

Date: a year ago

Review №80

Rating: 5

GOOOOOD PIZZA MELTS IN YOUR MOUTH

Date: a year ago

Review №81

Rating: 3

We ordered ahead but hadnt paid yet. When I came in to pick up my order after a very long day of traveling, they left my food out on the rack. When I said I was there for my order, they said it was on the rack. Someone from the back asked if it was paid for? The server asked me ( it seems like they should have known the answer), and I said no. They kept me waiting another 7 minutes. They put together 2 other orders, cleaned off a table, disappeared into the kitchen, and then came to ring me out. By the time I got out the door, the pizza was luke warm at best. We shouldnt have had to get home, preheat a pizza stone to reheat our food. It kind of defeats the purpose of ordering out dont ya think? They need to be more organized.

Date: a year ago

Review №82

Rating: 5

Great Italian food!

Date: a year ago

Review №83

Rating: 5

WE GOT LASAGNA WITH MEAT. IT WAS ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS. AND YOU GET A BIG ENOUGH SERVING THAT I BROUGHT A BIG CONTAINER HOME. Parking: THERE WAS NO PROBLEM FINDING A PARKING SPACE.

Date: a year ago

Review №84

Rating: 1

My son and I went for an early dinner. He had the cheese tortellini and I had the chicken Alfredo. My dish was flavorless and the chicken was overcooked and tough. My sons dish was way overcooked and his pasta was mush. The pink sauce was also flavorless. We were the only table for most of our meal and my water glass went empty without our waitress ever checking on us. It is sad that the best part of the meal was the bread and water. I had takeout several months ago and it was also bad. I will not be giving this restaurant another chance.

Date: a year ago

Review №85

Rating: 5

Great food, great price, fast service.

Date: a year ago

Review №86

Rating: 5

Quick, take out dinner

Date: a year ago

Review №87

Rating: 5

I have been here alot I am NEVER dissatisfied or disappointed with this restaurant. The service and food are always outstanding!! Food

Date: a year ago

Review №88

Rating: 5

Kid-friendliness: Family place that accommodates to all ages Food

Date: a year ago

Review №89

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №90

Rating: 5

This place is amazing! Authentic home made Italian food! This is a hidden gem! Everyone here is so nice! Every dish is delicious! Food

Date: a year ago

Review №91

Rating: 5

Fresh food fantastic deliciousness

Date: a year ago

Review №92

Rating: 2

The restaurant was very slow but we still waited over30 minutes for two pasta dishes. Vey disappointed in service and food

Date: a year ago

Review №93

Rating: 2

I was really craving a Sicilian pizza after not having one in so long. So, I gave this restaurant a try. Their deep dish pie didnt really taste authentic. It was very bready. More like a fake Sicilian. The restaurant itself is not in the greatest location, and the girl that I collected the takeout order from was nicer on the phone than in person (robotic and wouldnt give any eye contact).

Date: a year ago

Review №94

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №95

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №96

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №97

Rating: 5

I am Italian, so I look for places other than chain pizza places or Olive Garden (trash) when I am traveling. The pizza was great, and so was our sampler platter. They also bake their own bread, which is fantastic and unique. The mini cannolis are delicious too. You also can bring your own beer, which had I have known, I would have, and I would have shared em with anyone that wanted one. If youre impatient, uncultured, uneducated, etc. like others who leave malicious reviews for this place, go eat at Olive Garden with your kind... Also, Liv is a sweetheart, true Texas, a great server with an actual smile on her face. Eat here if you like authentic, good Italian food and want great service!

Date: a year ago

Review №98

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №99

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №100

Rating: 5

Its close to my heart so to speak. Down to earth restaurant. Great food! Kid-friendliness: They love my family coming to visit as much as we do. Food : 5/5 |

Date: a year ago

Review №101

Rating: 1

The toppings were running off the pizza. Very bland and the toppings were not cooked. The salad with one tomato slice was ok. Would not recommend at all.

Date: a year ago

Review №102

Rating: 2

2 large Pizzas $44 1 pepperoni 1 alfredo, spinach, chicken, mushrooms Forty Four Dollars for 2 large Pizzas and we picked it up.

Date: a year ago

Review №103

Rating: 3

The pizza was pretty good. The spaghetti with meat sauce well they didnt have any meat sauce on it really. Management probably needs to do some quality control.

Date: a year ago

Review №104

Rating: 3

Date: a year ago

Review №105

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №106

Rating: 5

Absolutely delicious. Welcoming staff! We ll be back!!!

Date: a year ago

Review №107

Rating: 4

Date: a year ago

Review №108

Rating: 3

Its a simple and local owned Italian restaurant. Its very quiet and not very busy so thats nice compared to a better known chain restaurant in the area. The service is friendly and the food comes out within a decent amount of time. Their menu is manageable so if you like pasta or Italian food, you may find something you like on their menu.

Date: a year ago

Review №109

Rating: 5

Great place! Great food! Great people

Date: a year ago

Review №110

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №111

Rating: 5

This place never disappoints. Consistently very good food, amazing customer service, and great vibes from everyone in the establishment. Anytime I visit this part of Texas I make it a priority to visit here!

Date: a year ago

Review №112

Rating: 1

Didn t get the correct order. Got something different than what I ordered. Poor Customer Service,

Date: a year ago

Review №113

Rating: 1

The spaghetti sauce tasted like straight tomato paste, my mom got the tour of Italy and it looked terrible and didnt taste any better it used to be a good place to eat not anymore terrible! Zero stars tbh on top of everything they charged for the water! $2.49! People dont go here theyre horrible!

Date: a year ago

Review №114

Rating: 2

Pizza was good, charged my card twice for the same meal. I understand mistakes happen, but at least try to communicate with me to fix the problem. I tried to call but didn t realize they weren t open on Monday s, called again on Tuesday, no answer. Left a voicemail explaining what happened. Never heard anything back.

Date: a year ago

Review №115

Rating: 2

Wait staff is inexperience and not friendly they sct like hooters wantabe which will never make the cut.

Date: a year ago

Review №116

Rating: 5

One of my family s favorite places for Italian in McKinney and is family owned and operated. My personal favorite is the Chicken Cacciatore and the fresh baked dinner rolls with pink sauce.

Date: a year ago

Review №117

Rating: 4

I ate at Sicily s for the first time at lunch today. The food was delicious. I ordered the Stromboli, which was enough for two meals (although I did eat all of it!). The service was fantastic. Both the owner and our server, Amelia, took great care to make sure we were satisfied. I ll definitely go back!!

Date: a year ago

Review №118

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №119

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №120

Rating: 4

Food is always good. Get the chicken albanese.

Date: a year ago

Review №121

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №122

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №123

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №124

Rating: 4

Date: a year ago

Review №125

Rating: 4

Went just after lunch time on Tuesday. Hardly anyone in there! Food was great - we had a large pizza half n half. The bread they brought first was amazing. TONS of cheese on the pizza. Only complaint I have is the spinach on the pizza was canned. Would have been perfect if it was fresh!

Date: a year ago

Review №126

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №127

Rating: 4

So-called reviewer Abigail Peña has no idea what they are talking about. I have both eaten during dinner times and ordered delivery and everything has been either up to or exceeding of expectations. Will continue to give this restaurant my money until the day I die. Abigail Peña is an absolute amateur and likely a pest when it comes to being a customer.

Date: a year ago

Review №128

Rating: 5

Excellent food. Very friendly staff. Mainstaple for Italian food in McKinney.

Date: a year ago

Review №129

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №130

Rating: 5

Excellent place and their food is delicious

Date: a year ago

Review №131

Rating: 5

Excellent friendly service and food...

Date: a year ago

Review №132

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №133

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №134

Rating: 5

We decided to have dinner at Sicily s (McKinney) during the week. Parking lot was very full. Nice young lady sat us and apologized in advance for the wait due to being short-handed. We were observing these 3 young ladies working their tails off with grace. We didn t experience any delays. Food was delicious! Service was top notch. Cameron was in charge that night and I have to say, she and the others were amazing. I found out they were younger than we thought, so they deserve even more compliments. Highly recommend. Portions are HUGE and prices are very reasonable. Vegetarian options: Many options Parking: Easy parking lot Kid-friendliness: Kid options

Date: a year ago

Review №135

Rating: 5

Has delicious homemade bread soft and right out of the oven. Every dish is great! We keep coming back.

Date: a year ago

Review №136

Rating: 3

Is more like a fast food Italian place.

Date: a year ago

Review №137

Rating: 2

We have eaten here for more than 15 years and always enjoyed it. Last night I ordered the Fettuccine Alfredo. It was basically warm milk with noodles. Very runny and flavorless. Despite talking to 3 people, nothing was done. The order also rang up a dollar more than what was posted on the menu and the clerk refused to adjust it. Im sorry to say it will definitely be a long time before I ever try again. I understand an off night but refusal to accommodate inadequacy is unacceptable.

Date: a year ago

Review №138

Rating: 1

Pasta is so bland, at least put some salt!

Date: a year ago

Review №139

Rating: 5

Love Avery! Shes so sweet!

Date: a year ago

Review №140

Rating: 2

the pizza was horrible. I love pizza shops. The crust was wet and soggy. The sauce is thin. Not sure if maybe they have other items that are good because this place is always packed. They also messed up my order. They forgot to include a meat item I asked for.

Date: a year ago

Review №141

Rating: 5

This is my new favorite place. The food is absolutely phenomenal. Seriously the best Italian Ive had in DFW, especially at the price point. The owner is also super friendly and the servers were attentive. I cant recommend it enough.

Date: a year ago

Review №142

Rating: 1

Had a party come in to try this place out. Was our first time. We ordered different pizzas and different pasta entrees. Everyone that had pasta did not like it one but and no one could finish what they ordered. People who ordered pizza were split on liking and not liking. Waitress did a decent job. Will not be back and would not recommend.

Date: a year ago

Review №143

Rating: 3

So Googlers, I know now that I live in the country, Princeton, that I would stop reviewing. Wrong! So my favorite food is Italian. So when I read that Sicilys Pizza & Pasta is where the, Real Italianians go I had to. Sorry to say, molto deluso. The appetizer, the Home Bread, was recommended by our friendly waitress. Soggy tomatoes on some sort of bread with sliced white cheese. Molto Deluso! I ordered the Eggplant w/ Italian sausage and my wife the Chicken Alfredo. My dish was passable. But my wifes Alfredo was watery. Ive tasted better alfredo and red sauce out of a jar on aisle 6 at Kroger. And thats the main problem here. The food lacked flavor, color and imagination. My wife commented the her Alfredo was just boring white. Peas, scallions, hell parsley! I know a ton of people go here and that its a McKinney institution. Maybe its the pizza? We will try that on the next visit, cause everyone deserves a second chance. Parking: In a small shopping strip, so plenty of parking. Kid-friendliness: Its a family environment.

Date: a year ago

Review №144

Rating: 5

Mushroom chicken pasta was delicious. The crusty bread is fantastic with the goop sauce. Recommend.

Date: a year ago

Review №145

Rating: 5

Very quick service. Clean tables. Food was great.

Date: a year ago

Review №146

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №147

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №148

Rating: 4

Date: a year ago

Review №149

Rating: 5

Prepare to ask for a to-go box. Large portions. However, its quality AND quantity here. The food is really excellent, in addition to being voluminous. Watch out for the fresh-cooked bread rolls. Theyre planetary in size. Dont fill up on em before you get your main meal.

Date: a year ago

Review №150

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №151

Rating: 2

Pizza was really greasy

Date: 2 years ago

Review №152

Rating: 5

The pizza was very very rusty! I m a good way!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Date: 2 years ago

Review №153

Rating: 4

Good service for dine in. Calzone It was pretty good. Not great though. Ill have to try it again to get this rating up.

Date: 2 years ago

Review №154

Rating: 5

Fantastic Italian food that covers all the bases for reasonable prices.

Date: 2 years ago

Review №155

Rating: 5

Great place for good food and service. Has been a part of the community for several years

Date: 2 years ago

Review №156

Rating: 4

Date: 2 years ago

Review №157

Rating: 5

This has been my neighborhood Italian for almost 30 years and every experience has been awesome. Sausage and pepper parm is my favorite and lasagna is my wifes favorite.

Date: 2 years ago

Review №158

Rating: 5

Date: 2 years ago

Review №159

Rating: 5

Family restaurant. Owner makes you feel welcomed. Food is yummy and prices are good. Our family dines there several times a week.

Date: 2 years ago

Review №160

Rating: 1

This place is for food! Anyhow I am a restaurant believer so Ill invite folk! Bye! This place describes myself needs learning a bit to do a restaurant thing. How comfortable!

Date: 2 years ago

Review №161

Rating: 2

Not a good first experience. Ordered the chicken parmesan w/ pink sauce. Chicken tasted like it was old and it was tuff to cut. Spaghetti was overcooked and sauce was very bland. Definitely not recommending. Told staff about chicken tasting old and all I got was a sorry. smh.... Also sounded like cook was more interested in flirting with staff than caring about quality of food. Very disappointing.

Date: 2 years ago

Review №162

Rating: 5

Food is amazing, so good... prices are great

Date: 2 years ago

Review №163

Rating: 5

A favorite of ours for the last 2 decades! I love the linguini in their spectacular white clam sauce. I would truly love to try something else, but I cant seem to get past the memories of that perfect linguini. My wifes favorite is the chicken carchovie. The only downside is the rolls. They are very heavy and not too tasty. But we warm them up in the microwave the next day and smear them with butter. Mmmm, mmmm! And on top of all that, Sicilys prices are extremely reasonable. All said, this just has to be one of McKinneys best restaurants. Check em out for some great Italian eating!

Date: 2 years ago

Review №164

Rating: 4

Great service!

Date: 2 years ago

Review №165

Rating: 5

Date: 2 years ago

Review №166

Rating: 5

Tues and Thurs specials are good

Date: 2 years ago

Review №167

Rating: 5

Good food. The margarita pizza is awesome and we enjoy the lasagna as well. I would definitely hit this place up again and again. P.S. the bread is big af and really good. Try the goop and pink sauce.

Date: 2 years ago

Review №168

Rating: 5

Date: 2 years ago

Review №169

Rating: 3

Date: 2 years ago

Review №170

Rating: 4

This restaurant is great. We go pretty often. But this time the cheese pizza wasnt good. Well my sons cheese was but my one slice wasnt. Everything else was fine. Just my one slice. As you can tell the last pic is my slice it doesnt look like the rest.

Date: 2 years ago

Review №171

Rating: 1

This was the worst pizza I have ever had. First, our pizza was messed up. We ordered the veggie feta , none of the toppings listed on the menu were on that pizza. The toppings put on our pizza weren t even on other pizzas in the menu.The pizza was extremely bland, way WAY too much cheese, the cheese was almost chewy like gum, and the pizza had barely any of the toppings. We would ve gotten a cheese pizza if we wanted nothing but cheese. This was supposed to be veggie. We were so excited for our pizza, because of how hungry we were.This was honestly so disappointing.

Date: 2 years ago

Review №172

Rating: 4

Date: 2 years ago

Review №173

Rating: 5

In my opinion this is the best pizza in McKinney..I had it for lunch today.

Date: 2 years ago

Review №174

Rating: 5

Quality. Great service w/ no thrills and phenomenal prices....even better then what I already mentioned is the portion sizes. This is a ma & pa business for sure.

Date: 2 years ago

Review №175

Rating: 5

Date: 2 years ago

Review №176

Rating: 1

Food used to be really good, it s absolutely terrible now and higher priced. Don t waste your time here.

Date: 2 years ago

Review №177

Rating: 5

Love their vegetarian pasta food choices. Eduardo is super friendly and attentive. Its a clean and friendly environment. Love this place , love the people.

Date: 2 years ago

Review №178

Rating: 5

Date: 2 years ago

Review №179

Rating: 5

Sicilys Pizza & Pasta has great clam linguine and pizza was good too. Go there all the for some Italian cravings. Good family invironment for those who likes some home good meals, mothers day and other celebrations. Very friendly and helpful servers.

Date: 2 years ago

Review №180

Rating: 5

Date: 2 years ago

Review №181

Rating: 5

The absolute best Italian food. The ingredients where fresh. The sauces made from scratch. I had the chicken Parmigian. The chicken was cooked and breaded to perfection. The staff was very friendly and knowledgeable. Our waitress whos initials where E.K was very sweet and attentive. If Im ever in the area I will definitely be back.

Date: 2 years ago

Review №182

Rating: 5

Incredible homemade meal here with a down home feel. The waitress, E.Q did a fantastic job and was extremely sweet. Would definitely go back.

Date: 2 years ago

Review №183

Rating: 5

Best pizza in Texas hands down

Date: 2 years ago

Review №184

Rating: 5

Really amazing food. BYOB Pizza is wonderful and their garlic rolls need to be the best Ive ever had.

Date: 2 years ago

Review №185

Rating: 5

My family loves the food at Sicilys Pizza! Their meatball parm grinders are delicious & big!

Date: 2 years ago

Review №186

Rating: 5

Date: 2 years ago

Review №187

Rating: 1

waiters are nice, food is okay, but the kitchen and atmosphere is disgusting and outdated. wannabe hole in the wall restaurant. don t recommend

Date: 2 years ago

Review №188

Rating: 5

Really good.

Date: 2 years ago

Review №189

Rating: 5

Great service

Date: 2 years ago

Review №190

Rating: 2

NEVER order here during dinner rush and NEVER do delivery! They just threw everything into the bag, it was leaking. I ordered their lasagna, no ricotta, with side meatballs, mushrooms and marinara they served the lasagna with ricotta (and Im allergic to ricotta) I expected there to be an individual container for the meatballs, but nope, they threw it into the container with my lasagna, they also threw that piece of bread into the bag without any container, had to get my own bowl to set it up how I wanted it, the bread was cold and soggy. Overall flavor is just eh, Ive worked in Italian food restaurants for two years now and Im disappointed. I decided to eat the meatballs and not risk it with the lasagna, I am getting an allergic reaction in my throat already. If you got allergies, please be careful, they shouldve just called me to change my order, but they didnt put the ingredients on their website or any others. I know when its dinner time, its difficult, but you must prioritize what the customer wants/needs and put thought and care into the orders. Even if youre going slower than usual, youre making sure the order is correct, it saves more time and more money if you dont mess up. Period.

Date: 2 years ago

Review №191

Rating: 2

Really wanted to like this place due to the good reviews but was disappointed sadly. We love to give our money to small businesses but this place did not hit it out of the ball park. No taste in the shrimp alfredo and the sausage was forgotten in hubbys ziti had to ask for it tasted like it came out of microwave. Only good thing is portions bigger then olive garden. Wont be coming back . Coffee was made in a cheap little coffee maker. I make better coffee at home :(

Date: 2 years ago

Review №192

Rating: 5

Outstanding service and the appetizer rolls were huge and delicious.

Date: 2 years ago

Review №193

Rating: 5

I ve been going here for years now and will continue to go as long as they have the great food and service they ve continued to have for so long. Great food, great service, great pricing, and bring your own vino, what more could you want?

Date: 2 years ago

Review №194

Rating: 4

Date: 2 years ago

Review №195

Rating: 1

Pizza and veggies were COLD.

Date: 2 years ago

Review №196

Rating: 5

Date: 2 years ago

Review №197

Rating: 5

Great pizza and pasta dishes! Owner Eddie is always welcoming you with a smile! He steps up to help clean tables when waitresses are serving! Cassie is a great server!

Date: 2 years ago

Review №198

Rating: 5

This place is great. Our server Mallory was fantastic and was really great with our 3 year old who loves to ask question. Service was a bit slow but in these times I dont mind because the food was fantastic! Will definitely be going again when we get a chance.

Date: 2 years ago

Review №199

Rating: 5

Date: 2 years ago

Review №200

Rating: 5

This is an authentic italian restaurant. I am fascinated with the food, it was great. The bread is the best.

Date: 2 years ago