Pie Society

Review №1

Rating: 5

My New Yorker in-laws said the pizza was great! The calzones were also delicious and very large! Parking: The lot is shared with several other businesses so could be difficult depending on time of day.

Date: a week ago

Review №2

Rating: 5

Date: a week ago

Review №3

Rating: 5

Date: 3 weeks ago

Review №4

Rating: 5

Great pizza!

Date: 4 weeks ago

Review №5

Rating: 5

Nice place friendly staff. I will come again.

Date: 4 weeks ago

Review №6

Rating: 5

Love this place, I run a store near by & often close on Wed this has been my go to place during my lunch hour. Love the pizza, the vibe, and salads. The employees are great and always seem happy. Service is quick and food is always amazing .

Date: 4 weeks ago

Review №7

Rating: 4

Ive been here a few times. Id like to give it a 5 star review, but they recently (or at least it wasnt there last time I visited,) a credit card fee. This is the second SM bar/restaurant ive been to that has added a CC fee. A CC fee is a business expense. Me paying a $1.00 CC fee, which lessened my experience because of the mere fact of its existence, not even the cost, is NOT worth it for the business. Our pizza took just under 30 minutes. Which is a bit longer than Id hope for a place that doesnt have wait service. You go up and order the food/beer, and return to your table with the number. The beer selection is a little lacking for a place that has taps. One IPA, two in-house (a margarita and a sangria,) one pilsner, a blonde, and I forget what the sixth beer was. 4 stars. I may return, but I wont be in a hurry to. Once again, the CC fee is immediately at the top of the POS screen before you even order anything. So the first thing the customer sees is a CC fee thats passed onto the customers before they even order anything. Its really off-putting, and like I said, in this instance, with the CC fee and the 30 minute wait for ONE pie, its a 4/5.

Date: a month ago

Review №8

Rating: 5

I had an outstanding experience at pie society thanks to John! From the moment we walked in, Tony greeted us with a warm smile, cracked some jokes, ensured our order was perfect. His friendly demeanor made our visit truly enjoyable. It s clear he takes great pride in his work, and it really shows in the quality of service he provides. Highly recommend Pie Society and John s exceptional service!

Date: a month ago

Review №9

Rating: 1

If you want a dry pizza with no toppings then I would rate it a 5

Date: a month ago

Review №10

Rating: 5

Date: a month ago

Review №11

Rating: 5

Always a treat! We have been coming here for pizza and beer for 4 years. together as a family or for a date night. Truly, the BEST pizza joint around.

Date: a month ago

Review №12

Rating: 5

Date: a month ago

Review №13

Rating: 5

Date: a month ago

Review №14

Rating: 5

Best pizza ever. Especially with the gluten free and vegan accommodations. Will come back everytime we re in San Marcos!

Date: a month ago

Review №15

Rating: 5

First time at this establishment, pizza was good but I expected better from the reviews. Service was excellent, checked on us several times and mad sure we were happy. That goes a long way in todays world . We will go back and try it again.

Date: a month ago

Review №16

Rating: 5

This pizza place is AMAZING. The flavors of the toppings are great. They have a lot of signature pizzas which are pretty classic but with a nice twist. The special that I had was super good and was a flavor that I never had on a pizza before. It was an al pastor flavor. One of the best pizzas that Ive ever had and I would totally recommend eating here.

Date: a month ago

Review №17

Rating: 5

Love this place - amazing pizza, good beers and nice staff always working here. Highly recommend for dine in or for hosting a party and having some great pizza!

Date: a month ago

Review №18

Rating: 5

Date: a month ago

Review №19

Rating: 5

Awesome pizza, great selection of beers, and courteous & laid-back staff make this a great place to go. Outdoor seating is a bonus! Now if they could only do Chicago deep dish . . .

Date: a month ago

Review №20

Rating: 5

Date: 2 months ago

Review №21

Rating: 4

Date: 2 months ago

Review №22

Rating: 5

Date: 2 months ago

Review №23

Rating: 5

ABSOLUTELY LOVE LOVE THE FOOD AND SERVICE!! 10 stars

Date: 2 months ago

Review №24

Rating: 5

Amazing pizzas!!!

Date: 2 months ago

Review №25

Rating: 5

Date: 2 months ago

Review №26

Rating: 5

Date: 2 months ago

Review №27

Rating: 5

I recently visited Pie Society and had an exceptional experience. From the moment we walked in, the staff was incredibly friendly, making us feel welcome. The atmosphere was amazing, providing a comfortable and enjoyable dining environment. Service was impressively fast, which we appreciated. The prices were decent, offering good value for the quality of food served. Speaking of the food, the pizza was both visually appealing and absolutely delicious. My daughter had a meatball sandwich, which she thoroughly enjoyed. The pizzas we ordered were equally fantastic. Overall, Pie Society exceeded our expectations in every way. I highly recommend this place for anyone looking for great pizza and excellent customer service.

Date: 2 months ago

Review №28

Rating: 5

Date: 2 months ago

Review №29

Rating: 5

Amazing slices sold by themselves

Date: 2 months ago

Review №30

Rating: 5

Date: 2 months ago

Review №31

Rating: 5

Great little pizza place! The staff noticed my 4 y/o getting restless and brought her out some raw dough to play with and some temporary tattoos. Such a great place!

Date: 2 months ago

Review №32

Rating: 5

You can order a whole pie or by the slice and the slices are huge

Date: 3 months ago

Review №33

Rating: 5

Stunning good pizza. They have arrived!!! This is the best pizza you can get. I promise !!!

Date: 3 months ago

Review №34

Rating: 5

Great pizza for a good price

Date: 3 months ago

Review №35

Rating: 5

Listen. From a pizza expert here, just go eat the pizza at this spot. Now. Normally I don t like too many toppings but this place has actual fresh toppings and flavor. Super friendly service. Love the conspiracy theme too, chill vibe. Absolutely phenomenal garlic knots too which is super difficult to find for some reason.

Date: 3 months ago

Review №36

Rating: 2

Date: 3 months ago

Review №37

Rating: 5

Pie Society is my family s go to pizza in town. It s literally THE best pizza around! The employees are wonderful too. I brought in my twin daughters in with me and waited for an order to go and the staff gave the girls a little dough to play with while we were waiting and they thought it was the coolest thing ever and told their dad that they got to make the pizza . Thanks for all the good times and The Enlightenment is my favorite pizza Iv ever had.

Date: 3 months ago

Review №38

Rating: 5

Great Pizza!

Date: 3 months ago

Review №39

Rating: 4

It was my first time at this place, and the experience was good; the bar tender was awesome, and the ambient was really friendly. If I pass back again in this area, for sure I will stop by. Beers and spirits are good, and dont forget the pizza.

Date: 3 months ago

Review №40

Rating: 5

Pie Society gave us great service! Small mishap but they fixed it quickly while keeping an excellent customer service and a smile on their face!! Thank y all!

Date: 3 months ago

Review №41

Rating: 4

Date: 3 months ago

Review №42

Rating: 5

Date: 3 months ago

Review №43

Rating: 5

I ve loved Pie Society for their pizza for YEARS, but this past week really took it to another level. A friend was hosting her wedding rehearsal dinner and their manager, Austin, went above and beyond to help make it an amazing experience. From helping us to reserve tables, to providing service and food that was top notch, it was actually the BEST!!

Date: 3 months ago

Review №44

Rating: 5

This is my husband and I s favorite place ever. We moved away a year ago and still yearn for this pizza we miss Texas but miss this place even more! Can t wait to go back and visit!

Date: 3 months ago

Review №45

Rating: 5

Manager Austin and the entire Pie Society team was AMAZING for our rehearsal dinner this week! They made sure we were well taken care of and hosted us during their tenth anniversary weekend. I have been a loyal Pie Society patron for the past decade and will continue to support all that the Katz brothers, their awesome manager Austin, and everyone at Pie Society does for years to come!!

Date: 3 months ago

Review №46

Rating: 4

I like the fact that they put little sauce, the cheese and topping are ample and the service is good. Tried other placed in San Marcos and always return to Pie Society

Date: 3 months ago

Review №47

Rating: 5

The goat cheese appetizer is wonderful. The pizza was delicious. This was our second time to visit the restaurant. We will keep going back.

Date: 3 months ago

Review №48

Rating: 5

Date: 4 months ago

Review №49

Rating: 5

Date: 4 months ago

Review №50

Rating: 5

Date: 4 months ago

Review №51

Rating: 5

Its my favorite pizza place! Decent prices and a full bar, get the goat cheese appetizer!

Date: 4 months ago

Review №52

Rating: 5

Oh yeah. My favorite pizza in San marcos

Date: 4 months ago

Review №53

Rating: 5

Both Austin (if memory serves, he is a manager there) and Bruce (the owner) were extremely helpful as me and my bride planned for Pie Society to cater our wedding of 76 individuals! Austin was very friendly and helpful in ensuring we both could do a proper taste test at Pie Society, and Bruce helped us coordinate everything for the big day! Though we didnt get a chance to meet any of those who delivered our pizza the day of our wedding, the food was delivered on time and was warmed well. For those who have eaten here before, you know how extremely tasty their selection is! We went with The Balance of Power, The Handshake, The Holy Grail, The Garden of Eden, Cheese Pizza, and their salads. In addition, Pie Society was able to accommodate some super tricky dietary restrictions for several of our guests including both gluten and dairy-free options, which was very helpful for us to ensure our guests felt especially welcomed. And to top it all off, we were able to beat another venue which included catering by ~$3 per individual which as any wedding-planning couple knows adds up fast! We would highly recommend considering Pie Society as a choice caterer for anyones next event--wedding or otherwise (and well be back as a married couple to enjoy pizza for a nice, casual date night in the future)! Dietary restrictions: Able to do gluten and dairy free personal-sized pizzas!

Date: 4 months ago

Review №54

Rating: 5

Date: 4 months ago

Review №55

Rating: 5

Best pizza I have ever had in my life! I would marry this pizza! I would go in business with this pizza! I would take this pizza on a one way trip to Mars! I would call this pizza when Im at the lowest point in my life and I need my best friend to lift me back up again! Thank you for giving this gift to the people!

Date: 5 months ago

Review №56

Rating: 5

Pie society never fails excellent pizza great service and atmosphere you cannot go wrong here!

Date: 5 months ago

Review №57

Rating: 5

Date: 5 months ago

Review №58

Rating: 5

Very pleases with every aspect of my visit. Will be back

Date: 5 months ago

Review №59

Rating: 5

We had their spicy specialty pizza. It was piping hot and spicy and hands down the best pizza Ive had in a while. It was definitely worth the trip from Cedar Park.

Date: 5 months ago

Review №60

Rating: 5

My favorite pizza spot in San Marcos. My favorites are the Holy Grail and the Balance of Power. But everything I ve tried has been remarkable and the staff are always very attentive and friendly.

Date: 5 months ago

Review №61

Rating: 5

Great place. Our favorite pizza for both takeout and dine in. Love the vibe, the consistency, the pizza special and the fun fountain sodas!

Date: 5 months ago

Review №62

Rating: 5

I get pizza from pie society at least once a month. The balance of power is delicious.

Date: 5 months ago

Review №63

Rating: 4

The pies were outstanding. I have missed real Northeast Pizza but this takes its place. The standard peperoni is as greasy and delicious as it should be, and the Garden of Eden were crave able delights of perfectly cooked veggies with depth of flavor. Only complaint was that while we sat outside a few of the tables were not bused and there were birds all over the table next to us. When the picnic table was bused the table was never wiped clean. Inside had a cool vibe. Hang out at the bar, or at a long table in a group or grab a slice and enjoy the energy of everyone there.

Date: 6 months ago

Review №64

Rating: 5

Awesome pizza

Date: 6 months ago

Review №65

Rating: 1

They claim to be the best pizza and claim they do a lot of weddings. Pizza was all cold before it was served to our guests. They said there was no way to keep the pizzas warm. Our guests had to eat cold pizza. Pizza was terrible and cold. I will never recommend this place for a party if you want to keep your pizzas warm. If I can give them a zero star I would. Even Jets pizza would have been better.

Date: 6 months ago

Review №66

Rating: 5

Date: 6 months ago

Review №67

Rating: 5

Date: 6 months ago

Review №68

Rating: 5

Date: 6 months ago

Review №69

Rating: 5

Date: 6 months ago

Review №70

Rating: 4

Always good!

Date: 6 months ago

Review №71

Rating: 4

Excellent Pie!!!

Date: 6 months ago

Review №72

Rating: 1

I used to have a five star review for this place, sadly, not any longer. I only ordered three slices of pizza. Two for me, and one for my little pookie bear. We ordered specific slices because they were obviously ready (you can see the pies by the slice when you walk in) and they took for ever. I had to wait in a long line a second time and ask about our order. I walked with the cashier over to their food line and someone had stabbed our ticket when they obviously hadn t brought out food. They told me I don t know what happened that s absolutely unacceptable. No one offered anything to make it right. Not even a sorry. Finally they brought our food out. I also don t appreciate the staff all making groaning sounds to communicate with each other. Completely unprofessional. Who s running this place? It seems like only teenagers or people are allowed to work here.I saw a girl with a nose ring and black hair counting plates and literally talking to herself. What is going on at pie society?

Date: 6 months ago

Review №73

Rating: 1

I dont know what has happened but the service and quality has gone way down

Date: 6 months ago

Review №74

Rating: 1

Never order here, they take forever and have horrible service.

Date: 7 months ago

Review №75

Rating: 5

Date: 7 months ago

Review №76

Rating: 5

Everything about this place is wonderful. Food is fresh, and delicious. Drinks are amazing - Im all for the Maine Root. Dessert is great. Its my favorite place to sit while on a break from classes. Great staff, wonderful management, clean facilities. Their in-house made salad dressing is to die for.

Date: 7 months ago

Review №77

Rating: 5

This small pizza restaurant is awesome. Pizza is Delicious and they have great beer. Staff is very friendly and the shop has a cool college town charm. Definitely a great place to grab lunch on the weekends.

Date: 7 months ago

Review №78

Rating: 5

Amazing pie!

Date: 7 months ago

Review №79

Rating: 5

Great pizza, good space

Date: 7 months ago

Review №80

Rating: 5

Date: 7 months ago

Review №81

Rating: 5

Date: 7 months ago

Review №82

Rating: 1

Called in for an order. Guy that answered asked if he could put me on a brief hold. He finally picked up the phone 9 minutes later as I was pulling into the parking lot. He said he had no help but as I walk in, there are employees standing around doing nothing. There should be at least one adult running this place. Manager came over and said sorry. Terrible service. If the Katz bros want to contact me to discuss, Ill be happy to change review.

Date: 7 months ago

Review №83

Rating: 5

Date: 7 months ago

Review №84

Rating: 4

Happy to say I finally found the best pizza in San Marcos. Sorry to say it took a few years. I d love to see better beer selections on tap as quantity on hand. Some nice IPA s from CO, OR would make this place an easy 5 for me. Only having Texas beer is sad.

Date: 7 months ago

Review №85

Rating: 5

Always delicious! The artichoke dip never misses! Vegetarian options: Goat cheese pizza, appetizers, salads, the boozy tomato pizza, the illuminati pizza Food : 5/5 |

Date: 7 months ago

Review №86

Rating: 5

Best vegan pizza ever

Date: 7 months ago

Review №87

Rating: 5

Super delicious and fresh pizza! I love their combos and also pizza topping options. The staff was friendly and the place was very clean. I would definitely come back!

Date: 8 months ago

Review №88

Rating: 5

Everything was delicious. Im coming back.

Date: 8 months ago

Review №89

Rating: 5

Delicious pizza at reasonable prices. High quality ingredients, unique pizzas

Date: 8 months ago

Review №90

Rating: 5

We held our companys staff party at Pie Society recently. It was a top-notch experience from planning to execution. They set up the room perfectly. Kailee, the manager on duty was super friendly and helpful and our server Sam went above and beyond to provide awesome hospitality . It goes without saying that the food was great. Ill put their pizza up against just about anybodys. Such a great local establishment!

Date: 8 months ago

Review №91

Rating: 3

Service very friendly and informative, but really slow. Maybe it was a difficult night? Sublime food.

Date: 8 months ago

Review №92

Rating: 5

Had a work party here and the food and drinks were great. Sam, our server, was super attentive even though there were a lot of us and was super accommodating. All around good atmosphere/food/experience.

Date: 8 months ago

Review №93

Rating: 5

Date: 8 months ago

Review №94

Rating: 5

Date: 8 months ago

Review №95

Rating: 5

Date: 8 months ago

Review №96

Rating: 5

Delish!

Date: 8 months ago

Review №97

Rating: 5

Very Good Pizza In San Marcos!

Date: 9 months ago

Review №98

Rating: 5

Date: 9 months ago

Review №99

Rating: 4

The thin crust has great flavor

Date: 9 months ago

Review №100

Rating: 5

Date: 9 months ago

Review №101

Rating: 4

Usually great service and the pizza is the best!!!

Date: 9 months ago

Review №102

Rating: 3

I usually love Pie Society, but the last time I went in (two weeks ago), the drinks we got tasted funny. I went up to get a different drink, and I saw there was black sludge all around the dispensers and behind the ice machine dispenser! It was so disgusting. It s honestly put me off wanting to go back, which is unfortunate because it was one of our favorite local restaurants.

Date: 9 months ago

Review №103

Rating: 4

Date: 9 months ago

Review №104

Rating: 1

Sad pizza. They told me 45 minutes for pick up. That pizza was way old by the time I got it home. Come to Pennsylvania, we can show you how to make a pizza. If I wasnt on vaca visiting my son, Id have taken it back. Should have opened the box before I left. Son was right, he said Pie Society is typically hit or miss

Date: 9 months ago

Review №105

Rating: 5

Absolutely the best pizza in the area.

Date: 9 months ago

Review №106

Rating: 5

Date: 9 months ago

Review №107

Rating: 4

Placed an online order and they forgot all my toppings. I called about it and they made my a new pizza, let me keep the old one, and fully refunded my order. I really appreciated the awesome customer service and amazing gluten free crust. Would be five stars if they were a little more generous with the toppings but overall great place.

Date: 9 months ago

Review №108

Rating: 5

Date: 9 months ago

Review №109

Rating: 3

We come here often. The food is wonderful but the service is the worst. For some reason they can never get our order right. Something is always missing or they forgot about putting the order in and it takes even longer. It s ridiculous. But the food is what keeps bringing us back.

Date: 9 months ago

Review №110

Rating: 5

i come here when im high

Date: 9 months ago

Review №111

Rating: 4

Date: 10 months ago

Review №112

Rating: 5

Dangerous good pizza

Date: 10 months ago

Review №113

Rating: 3

Normally its good pizza, but 3 weeks ago our pizza was very burnt, we didnt go back because it was already night and almost time for them to close

Date: 10 months ago

Review №114

Rating: 5

Got a calzone from here. It was one of the best I ve ever had.

Date: 10 months ago

Review №115

Rating: 5

Fantastic pizza! The crust was wonderful, the margaritas were strong and the service was friendly without being too overwhelming. Perfect experience

Date: 10 months ago

Review №116

Rating: 5

Generously potent margaritas, better than the ones I ve had at highly rated Italian and Mexican restaurants I ve recently been to. Pizza was awesome with hot honey, service was prompt and polite.

Date: 10 months ago

Review №117

Rating: 4

Date: 10 months ago

Review №118

Rating: 5

Definately a place to try out in San Marcos! They have creative, unique, and overall delicious menu items. Additonally, they are gluten freindly (a gluten free crust comes as a personal sized pizza only) and vegan friendly (in pizza, not just salads!!)

Date: 10 months ago

Review №119

Rating: 5

Always enjoy trying local craft beers ! Best pizza around! Food

Date: 10 months ago

Review №120

Rating: 5

One of the hidden gems in San Marcos, great place to pick up a slice! Always watch for the daily special!

Date: 10 months ago

Review №121

Rating: 4

Date: 11 months ago

Review №122

Rating: 5

Date: 11 months ago

Review №123

Rating: 5

Date: 11 months ago

Review №124

Rating: 2

It was my first time ordering pizza here and they TOTALLY messed up my order. I got half El Diablo and half the Enlightenment. First off, the El Diablo pizza half was COMPLETELY WRONG! They put pepperonis on it when it s supposed to have chicken and the only thing they did right with it was the sriracha sauce. Then, for the Enlightenment, it didn t have the brussel sprouts or any of the other intended toppings (it had mozzarella at least), and they added spinach. I guess they don t know how to make the pizzas on their menu.

Date: 11 months ago

Review №125

Rating: 5

Date: 11 months ago

Review №126

Rating: 4

Date: 11 months ago

Review №127

Rating: 4

Very good pizza, i personally like more flavorful sauce.

Date: 11 months ago

Review №128

Rating: 5

Lived up to the reviews I had read online. Hand tossed fired pizzas! We got the 78 666 pizza and it was delish! Also the bartender made a solid spicy Bloody Mary. Would return again!

Date: 11 months ago

Review №129

Rating: 5

Delicious! I am full but still want another slice. The El Diablo is the way to go for spicy, sweet, and savory. The chicken was so juicy and not overcooked.

Date: 11 months ago

Review №130

Rating: 5

Date: 11 months ago

Review №131

Rating: 5

Pie you will enjoy

Date: 11 months ago

Review №132

Rating: 5

Very impressed - from the moment we walked in, awesome atmosphere especially the preparation area which was a sight for the senses, the aroma, friendly engaged employees and the dough being tossed acrobatically in the air. We made a custom order and it was delivered exactly as ordered, hot and delicious. I indulged in a recommended seasonal mixed drink Smashing Pumkins which was really good and Mr. Nautti had a very cold bottled Dos Equis. The place was packed on a Saturday evening, outside dining available too. We sat inside where there are various seating options, barside, high tops, tables and tables for large groups. Order at the counter/bar which is well stocked for mixed drinks and draft, craft beers. Really terrific concept all-around. The most impressive is the dance being performed by each and every employee - we counted 8 employees at various stations busting their humps and delivering in style. Make sure you take time to watch how the pizzas are made - impressive. We went out of our way on our first visit here - we were driving back to ATX - our internet search was for pizza and mixed drinks - so very glad we found Pie Society, a locally owned small business. Well definitely be back.

Date: 11 months ago

Review №133

Rating: 1

Been coming to this place for years and it s always been great until today. Purposely ordered slices so that it could be fast but man, I m still here sitting in this table with a hungry child and the slices I ordered 45 min ago are still not ready. Management: if you have these many customers and you are not sufficiently staffed, please el the we close the damn kitchen and stop taking orders or be honest to the customers and say it will take 45 minutes for your staff of 2 on q Saturday to heat a slice. Never coming back.

Date: 11 months ago

Review №134

Rating: 5

Service and pizza were very superb... a little raucous and loud in the restaurant but being next to a college it is what it is...

Date: a year ago

Review №135

Rating: 4

Date: a year ago

Review №136

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №137

Rating: 5

Loved the pizza, for being a first-timer. The oven-baked pizza is not so greasy that you get to enjoy all the toppings. The margaritas are good. My favorite pizza was the 78-666 and The Holy Grail with the appetizer of Spinach Artichoke dip. Parking: Its inside a small marketplace with other restaurants so it can of hard to find a parking place.

Date: a year ago

Review №138

Rating: 4

Great pizza! Great small town college vibes. Parking: Limited number of spots in the lot. The lot is a decent size, but if the area is busy it may be difficult. Kid-friendliness: College kids having pizza with drinks. Maybe dont bring small kids. Take them to pizza hut somewhere else.

Date: a year ago

Review №139

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №140

Rating: 5

It doesnt suck! If they make a mistake, they make it right X2. Highly recommended. Vegetarian options: Their vegan cheese is pretty good and I like meat.

Date: a year ago

Review №141

Rating: 5

Quality ingredients, great food. Best Cesar salad Ive ever had. Highly recommend.

Date: a year ago

Review №142

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №143

Rating: 5

Ate here for the first time and enjoyed it very much. Staff was super nice, friendly and helpful.. food was awesome and its very spacious and cozy inside.

Date: a year ago

Review №144

Rating: 5

theyre nice (:

Date: a year ago

Review №145

Rating: 3

We were excited about this place based on the reviews but the pizza is honestly super mid. The dough is not anything special and I feel like that is what makes a pizza. The Caesar salad had barely any dressing on it. Glad we came by to try it but not for me.

Date: a year ago

Review №146

Rating: 5

Great food. Friendly staff

Date: a year ago

Review №147

Rating: 5

Great NY style pizza! Also terrific fresh salads (and Im not really a salad guy). I give it an 8.3

Date: a year ago

Review №148

Rating: 5

Excellent food and ambience.

Date: a year ago

Review №149

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №150

Rating: 5

Excellent food. Great service. Not just for the college crowd.

Date: a year ago

Review №151

Rating: 5

This is the best pie in the Hill Country. Crust and sauce are phenomenal.

Date: a year ago

Review №152

Rating: 5

All I am going to say is love the pizza. Parking: Parking is hard to find. Plenty other restaurants in the sanw area. Food : 5/5 |

Date: a year ago

Review №153

Rating: 5

Incredible..took my son down to school on a busy Friday.. starving...45 min to an hour everywhere else...got two pie ny style...best pizza and beer combo ever...great job

Date: a year ago

Review №154

Rating: 5

The pizza here is AMAZING. If you like thin crispy pizza then this is for you. Good flavor and there are many options. You can buy it by the slice or you can get whole pizzas. Overall 15/10 gotta recommend this place.

Date: a year ago

Review №155

Rating: 5

Super cute location and the pizza was super good!

Date: a year ago

Review №156

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №157

Rating: 5

Always amazing, great prices, so damn good!!!!

Date: a year ago

Review №158

Rating: 1

Closed?

Date: a year ago

Review №159

Rating: 3

Super super good food, but with their order process they always forget one of my items.

Date: a year ago

Review №160

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №161

Rating: 5

Were new to the area and figured we would give this place a try as were always on the lookout for good pizza, and we certainly werent disappointed! Fantastic pizza abs garlic knots - you can taste the freshness and the genuine desire to give their customers a superior product. Also, the service and atmosphere were great! We will definitely be back!

Date: a year ago

Review №162

Rating: 5

Fun atmosphere and super friendly staff, my daughter ate pepperoni and I had the special of the day and the Hand Shake. Bonus is it s next to a super coffee house Mocha s and Javas.

Date: a year ago

Review №163

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №164

Rating: 5

We arrived and they were just starting to have issues with their computer system. They took our order on paper and we waited. Then we waited, and we waited. They later told us there were some oven issues and gave us some free knots. Turns out they caught up, the pizza was good, the hustle was better and the manager Bruce was awesome. They apologized and of course it wasnt their fault, but we ended up with an extra pizza in the mix-up. ; ) We Will come back again and with the amount of orders it was impessive to see the catch up! Vegetarian options: Gluten Free options for those who choose too or have to ... ; ) and Vegan cheese if needed!

Date: a year ago

Review №165

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №166

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №167

Rating: 5

Best pizza in town. Hands down.

Date: a year ago

Review №168

Rating: 4

The pizza is great. We have never had anything that was less than stellar. The vibes in the place are great. This place is great if you are looking for college town food in a place that isn t run down like the square.

Date: a year ago

Review №169

Rating: 3

Food was good but not worth the price in my opinion. Too many college kids, but it seems like thats what they are going for. I really enjoyed their Cesar salad but I would rather make pizza and salad at home for the price.

Date: a year ago

Review №170

Rating: 1

Burnt pizza missing ingredients

Date: a year ago

Review №171

Rating: 5

As basic as it is, their pepperoni pizza is actually really good. The dressing that comes with the house salad is also tasty.

Date: a year ago

Review №172

Rating: 5

Delicious pizza and fun atmosphere.

Date: a year ago

Review №173

Rating: 5

Delicious pie! Lots of great options, we got the Illuminati and The Balance of Power, both were amazing. As a east coast native I find good hand tossed pizza is not easy to find in Texas but this place rivals some of the best I ve had!

Date: a year ago

Review №174

Rating: 5

Delicious pizza and Maine Root soda machine

Date: a year ago

Review №175

Rating: 5

The best pizza Ive ever had!

Date: a year ago

Review №176

Rating: 5

Fresh farm to table ingredients, making this the best pizza spot in town. Highly recommend!

Date: a year ago

Review №177

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №178

Rating: 1

Tonight the team members of Pie Society lost our to-go order for the third time. I was willing to forgive the first two times they lost or forgot my order, leaving me or my husband to sit and wait there for 30+ minutes before checking on the status of my order, but after the THIRD TIME of this occurring, I feel compelled to leave a review. While I have always enjoy the pizza (which is why I previously came back), the poor service and lack of organization is appalling. And to top it off, they never did or said anything to fix their mistakes on any of the three occasions. I am so disappointed.

Date: a year ago

Review №179

Rating: 2

The pizza really tastes great and I ve eaten here a lot but within the last year they have lost my ticket three separate times and the wait times are getting ridiculously long with servers who are either overworked or don t care

Date: a year ago

Review №180

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №181

Rating: 5

Supportive staff, very good pizza

Date: a year ago

Review №182

Rating: 5

They have cheese and pepperoni but also some pizza combos that are crazy and awesome.

Date: a year ago

Review №183

Rating: 4

People told me this place was amazing. Not sure how it s New York style , it was not like any pizza I had in NYC. It was good but not great. The staff was really nice. I can see how it s one of the best in town but didn t seem worth the cost.

Date: a year ago

Review №184

Rating: 3

We used to love Pie Society, but the service and quality has gone down. We went there today to use our free pie voucher we received from our previous visit due to messed up order. Our pizza was slightly over cooked again and we only received one of our 2 orders of marinara. When we asked for the second we were brought out a quarter of the normal serving.

Date: a year ago

Review №185

Rating: 5

Quick service and great pizza.

Date: a year ago

Review №186

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №187

Rating: 2

You guys mess up my order everytime. It s always a pepperoni with light cheese. I picked up my pizza today and it has practically no sauce it s dry as cardboard. Thank you

Date: a year ago

Review №188

Rating: 5

Best pizza in San Marcos. It s light, crispy, with traditional and some interesting toppings. I tried the Tiki Marsala, which wasn t my favorite but the cheese pizza and some other combos were delish. They also sell by the slice

Date: a year ago

Review №189

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №190

Rating: 5

This was one of the best pizzas I ve ever had. I will come back again if I m ever in town. The Balance of Power was just amazing, try it out.

Date: a year ago

Review №191

Rating: 5

My rating is ****1/2 out of 5. The staff was extremely nice. The service was incredible. The ambience was very warm and welcoming. The restaurant was very clean. And the food was great. What keeps this from reaching 5 stars is that the restrooms were pretty dirty and I do wish the pizza had more sauce. Minor gripes but a near perfect experience.

Date: a year ago

Review №192

Rating: 5

Found online so we took a ride to see how it was. Definitely a good spot to visit and enjoy a few slices of pizza .

Date: a year ago

Review №193

Rating: 4

Date: a year ago

Review №194

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №195

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №196

Rating: 5

My wife found this joint when she took a trip to San Marcos with friends and now it s become a great little day trip stop from our home in N Austin. The pizza is amazing (try the San Martian) and the salads are super fresh - all packaged in a super chill vibe. We love it.

Date: a year ago

Review №197

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №198

Rating: 5

The food was sooo good! Especially the spinach artichoke dip!

Date: a year ago

Review №199

Rating: 5

Date: a year ago

Review №200

Rating: 4

Very nice, helpful staff! Good food.

Date: a year ago